Precision Vehicle Peer Check

Complete this check while the prototype is still easy to change.

Feedback must lead to a decision

Record the exact observation, then accept, adapt, or reject the suggestion using evidence. “It looks good” is not enough information to guide an improvement.

Designer: brief walkthrough

Explain:

  • the intended propulsion path;
  • the most important success criterion;
  • one part that currently works;
  • one mechanical concern.

Reviewer: observe and respond

Give all three:

  1. Strength: identify a specific feature that supports controlled travel.
  2. Mechanical concern: identify a possible issue involving alignment, friction, traction, stability, durability, or consistency.
  3. Recommended check: suggest one safe inspection, measurement, or controlled test.

Avoid vague feedback such as “looks good” or “make it faster.” Connect the comment to an observable feature.

Designer: decide

Record the reviewer’s name and exact feedback. Choose one response:

  • Accept: follow the suggestion.
  • Adapt: use part of the idea in another way.
  • Reject with evidence: explain why another choice better meets the criteria.

Take a photograph before making the next change and document the response in Part 2 of the Notion entry.